What Days Are Referenced in Romans 14:5-6?
Some conclude that
Romans 14:5-6
authorizes people to observe any days they choose. By taking these
verses out of context, and applying their own meaning, they assert that
it makes no difference to God which days we keep.
In order to grasp the true intent of this passage, we must start reading where the context of the subject begins.
Verses 1-4 identify the subject in context as
vegetarianism—not which days should be kept.
Notice: “One
man esteems one day above another: another esteems every day alike. Let every man be
fully persuaded
in his own mind. He that regards the day, regards it unto the Lord; and
he that regards not the day, to the Lord he does not regard it. He that
eats,
eats to the Lord, for he gives God thanks; and he that
eats not, to the Lord he
eats not, and gives God thanks” (
Rom. 14:5-6).
Does Paul state here that Jesus, by His death, did away with the very days He kept during His entire life? No! Does he say, “
GOD esteems one day above another” and “
GOD esteems every day alike?” Again, no! The verse says, “One
MAN esteems one day above another.” This is telling us that it was what
men were teaching, not what God instructs.
Christ is not going to judge us by what any
man believes. He will judge us by His Word, the Bible: “…the
word that I have spoken,
the same shall judge him in the last day” (
John 12:48).
Notice that the saints at Rome were forbidden to
judge one another: “Who are you that judges another man’s servant? To his own master he stands or falls. Yes, he shall be helped up: for
God is able to make him stand” (
Rom. 14:4).
Paul is not condemning or endorsing a particular period of time for Sabbath observance or worship, but he
is warning the saints not to
judge
one another and cause strife by having differing opinions about when
people choose to semi-fast. Those in Rome were weak in the faith. They
had not yet matured spiritually. Paul says, “For I long to see you, that
I may
impart unto you some spiritual gift, to the end that you
may be established” (
Rom. 1:11).
This scripture in no way gives license to believe whatever you want. God commands, “…and lean not unto your own understanding” (
Prov. 3:5). Until you
know what God says
in His word, how can you be fully assured in your own mind what is
right? Paul stated, “the holy scriptures…are able to make you wise unto
salvation” (
II Tim. 3:15).
Paul is writing to both Jewish and Gentile converts at Rome. He advised them to accept those who were “weak in the faith” (
Rom. 14:1),
and to not “dispute” insignificant matters with them, nor sit in
judgment of them. Some of these newly converted Gentiles, being weak,
were still vegetarians and refused to eat meats.
The reason they did not eat meat is explained in
I Corinthians 8.
Most meat available for purchase at the market had been previously
offered to idols at pagan temples. Therefore, some, with conscience of
the idol, ate it “as a thing offered unto an idol; and their conscience
being
weak is defiled. But meat commends us not to God: for
neither, if we eat, are we the better; neither, if we eat not, are we
the worse” (
vs. 7-8).
Some of the converts at Rome, who had given up idolatry, were Gentiles.
Still being superstitious, they thought the idol had defiled the meat.
What were these days Paul was referring to? Why did Paul break into
this thought—about eating meat—and mention “days”? The answer is found
in the Moffatt translation: “Then again, this man rates one day above
another, while that man rates all days alike. Well, everyone must be
convinced in his own mind; the man who values a particular day does so
to the Lord. The
eater eats to the Lord, since he thanks God for his food; the
non-eater abstains to the Lord, and he too thanks God” (
Rom. 14:5-6).
Notice! Not only were there weak converts who avoided eating meat offered to idols, but others customarily
abstained
from particular foods. They semi-fasted on certain particular days.
Still others refused to practice a semi-fast or abstain from foods,
but regarded every day in the same way!
A number of Jews of that time held semi-fasts twice in the week (
Luke 18:12). Some would also fast during the fifth and seventh months (
Zech. 7:4-7).
They were divided as to exactly when to fast. The Gentile converts were
also divided as to what days to abstain from certain foods. Because of
the differing backgrounds of these people, they could not agree on which
days to do this. There were divisions in the congregation. Jesus taught
us that fasting is something that is done without making it obvious to
others (
Matt. 6:16). It is a personal matter—between an individual and God.
The subject of this question surrounded the matter of
abstinence
on particular days—upon which days many voluntarily abstained from
certain foods. It did not involve whether or not to keep pagan holidays
or God’s Holy Days.
Nowhere in this passage is there any reference to “Sabbaths,” “Holy Days” or “Feasts”!